Choosing the Right Water Heater for Efficiency and Cost Savings
/choosing-the-right-water-heater-for-efficiency-and-cost-savings/ ·
post
· scuff-batch-004 Optimized
Light Edit
Pass
Classification
- Page Type
- blog post
- Campaign Bucket
- water heater replacement
- Buyer Persona
- homeowner research
- Page Role
- consideration
- Query Family
- choosing water heaterwater heater efficiencybest water heater for savings
Audit Scores
Composite: 3.9 / 5
Intent Fit 4.0
Local Relevance 4.0
Service Clarity 4.0
Persona Fit 4.0
Trust Fit 4.0
Offer Fit 3.0
Conversion Ready 4.0
Page Stats
- Word Count
- 950
- Internal Links
- 0
- External Links
- 0
- Content Preserved
- 95.8%
- Tone Preserved
- Yes
- Words Before
- 950
- Words After
- 910
- NAP: Business Name
- ✓
- NAP: Phone
- ✓
- NAP: Address
- ✗
Issues (3)
0 violations,
0 weaknesses,
0 opportunities
Minor
Applied
financial-claim
Contains dollar amounts ($300-$1,000, $800-$3,000, $1,000-$3,000, $300-$1,500) and savings percentages (up to 30%, 10-20%, 24-34%, 60-70%) — these are sourced educational figures but policy prohibits dollar amounts and savings percentages
"$300 to $1,000 installed, reduce energy bills by up to 30%"
Before
accounts for 10–20% of total energy consumption
After
accounts for a notable share of total energy consumption
Minor
weakness-no-internal-links
Zero internal links on a medium-length blog post about water heaters
"links.json shows 0 internal, 0 external"
Info
nap-variant
CTA uses 'We The Plumbers' (canonical) and phone '936-Plumber (936-758-6237)' — correct
"We The Plumbers today at 936-Plumber (936-758-6237)"
QA Validation
Verdict: pass
Pass. All 7 blocking QA checks passed. This page is safe to commit.
Structural Safety
pass — only inline text within existing <p> elements modified; no structural changes blocking
Claim Fabrication
pass — removed all dollar amounts and savings percentages; replaced with qualitative language; no new claims blocking
NAP Consistency
pass — 'We The Plumbers' canonical name present; phone '936-Plumber (936-758-6237)' present blocking
Internal Links
pass — 0 internal links (unchanged), within limit for medium page (0-2 allowed) blocking
Violation Resolution
pass — CRW-01 all dollar amounts and savings percentages removed across 6 locations blocking
Scope Compliance
pass — text-only changes within existing paragraphs blocking
Geographic Compliance
pass — Conroe, Montgomery County, and Texas mentioned, all approved blocking
Trust & Readability
pass — no trust words in original or current; none added Blocked Items
pass — no blocked changes Manifest Accuracy
pass — changes.json documents 6 applied changes matching actual diff Preservation Verification
Original Words 950
New Words 910
Preserved 95.8%
Matches Optimizer Claim Yes
Changes (6)
6 applied, 0 blocked, 1 skipped
| Issue | Severity | Status | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
| CRW-01 | Minor | Applied | Replaced '10-20%' standby loss figure with qualitative language |
| CRW-01 | Minor | Applied | Replaced 'up to 30%' savings figure with qualitative language |
| CRW-01 | Minor | Applied | Replaced dollar amounts ($300-$1,000, $800-$3,000) with qualitative cost comparison |
| CRW-01 | Minor | Applied | Removed '60-70%' efficiency figure |
| CRW-01 | Minor | Applied | Replaced '24-34%' savings figure with qualitative language |
| CRW-01 | Minor | Applied | Replaced dollar amounts ($1,000-$3,000, $300-$1,500) with qualitative comparison |