S Scuff
We The Plumbers

Essential Guide to Water Heater Maintenance

/essential-guide-to-water-heater-maintenance/ ยท
post
ยท scuff-batch-004
Optimized
Light Edit
Pass
Classification
Page Type
blog post
Campaign Bucket
water heater replacement
Buyer Persona
homeowner proactive
Page Role
awareness
Query Family
water heater maintenance
water heater maintenance guide
how to maintain water heater
Audit Scores
Composite: 3.7 / 5
Intent Fit
4.0
Local Relevance
4.0
Service Clarity
4.0
Persona Fit
4.0
Trust Fit
4.0
Offer Fit
3.0
Conversion Ready
3.0
Page Stats
Word Count
1050
Internal Links
0
External Links
0
Content Preserved
99.8%
Tone Preserved
Yes
Words Before
1050
Words After
1048
NAP: Business Name
โœ—
NAP: Phone
โœ—
NAP: Address
โœ—
Issues (3)
0 violations, 0 weaknesses, 0 opportunities
Minor
Applied
financial-claim

States 'Each degree above 120F can increase energy costs by 3-5%' โ€” a savings percentage claim

"increase energy costs by 3โ€“5%"
Before
Each degree above 120ยฐF can increase energy costs by 3โ€“5%
After
Higher settings increase energy costs noticeably
Minor
Applied
nap-variant

CTA uses 'We The Plumbers TX' instead of canonical 'We The Plumbers'

"We The Plumbers TX is here to keep your system running"
Before
We The Plumbers TX
After
We The Plumbers
Minor
weakness-no-internal-links

Zero internal links on a long-form maintenance guide

"links.json shows 0 internal, 0 external"
QA Validation
Verdict: pass
Pass. All 7 blocking QA checks passed. This page is safe to commit.
Structural Safety
blocking
pass โ€” only inline text within existing <p> elements modified; no structural changes
Claim Fabrication
blocking
pass โ€” removed '3-5%' percentage; replaced with qualitative language; no new claims
NAP Consistency
blocking
pass โ€” fixed 'We The Plumbers TX' to canonical 'We The Plumbers'; no phone/address on page
Internal Links
blocking
pass โ€” 0 internal links (unchanged), within limit for long page (0-3 allowed)
Violation Resolution
blocking
pass โ€” EGM-01 percentage removed; EGM-02 NAP variant fixed
Scope Compliance
blocking
pass โ€” text-only changes within existing paragraphs
Geographic Compliance
blocking
pass โ€” Conroe and Montgomery County only, both approved
Trust & Readability
pass โ€” 'licensed' appears in original and retained; no new trust words
Blocked Items
pass โ€” no blocked changes
Manifest Accuracy
pass โ€” changes.json documents 2 applied changes matching actual diff

Preservation Verification

Original Words 1050
New Words 1048
Preserved 99.8%
Matches Optimizer Claim Yes
Changes (2)
2 applied, 0 blocked, 1 skipped
Issue Severity Status Description
EGM-01
Minor
Applied
Replaced '3-5%' savings percentage with qualitative language
EGM-02
Minor
Applied
Fixed NAP variant: 'We The Plumbers TX' -> 'We The Plumbers' (all occurrences)